Skip to main content

Hunting and the NRA


A friend of mine in DC occasionally sends me (or Tweets at me) articles that he wants my opinion on. Yesterday, it was an op-ed piece from the New York Times titled, "I Hunt, but the N.R.A. Isn’t for Me" by Lily Raff McCaulou. My buddy wanted to know, as a "lady hunter" what I thought about this. And I am curious what YOUR opinion is... are you a card carrying member of the NRA?

As I read the op-ed, I agreed with many of her points, For hunters like me, hunting isn’t ultimately about the gun. It’s about wildlife and the land that sustains it and I’m a hunter and a sportswoman. I own guns, but not for self-defense but I also have to wonder if her stats are truly correct "the most comprehensive national survey of firearm ownership to date found that only 35 percent of gun-owning households say they hunt. Even then, the N.R.A. would represent only about one-third of all hunters in the United States"

I don't know a lot (or anything really) about the NRA. The only thing that comes to mind is Charlton Heston, with the gun above his head, yelling "From my cold, dead hands!" And I know that is not me. I love my gun... I snuggle with my gun while I am in my tree seat, but there is only one gun at my house, and it's not mine.

So - there are many of you out there that have a lot more knowledge and thoughts on this topic. What do you think? Does McCaulou have a solid argument? How separate are the NRA and hunting? and is that good or bad? I would love to know what you all think.

Comments

  1. Downeast Duck HunterApril 26, 2012

    Simply put, the NRA supports everything I believe in when it comes to the 2nd amendment.

    Everything has a lobby today, so I'm fine that I support an organization that helps guard against policymakers whose prefer to regulate more and more and more.

    The NRA supports hunters even though a lot of hunters do not necessarily support the NRA.

    Get ready for some interesting banter, you may have loaded a gun here.

    DEDH

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kirk MantayApril 26, 2012

    There's no question that the NRA does good work on many fronts. But I personally cannot support them because one of their former board members is a 16-time (I think that's the right number) convicted federal firearms trafficker here in Maryland. NRA funds were used to defend him (unsuccessfully) in court, originally about 100 individual charges of selling handguns with no documentation. That's right, NO DOCUMENTS. NO PAPERWORK. In at least a half dozen cases, the guns he sold were traced to murders in the Baltimore heroin trade.

    While this NRA board member's federal charges were pending, the NRA was flying him around the country to attend donor events, advertising his appearance as "2nd amendment warrior Sandy Abrams." If you're looking for case studies on "why people have a stick up their ass about guns in America," this is one of those kind of reasons.

    In all fairness I do have to state that once he plead out to how ever many dozen federal firearms trafficking charges, the NRA did in fact remove him from their board of directors.

    But I have to flatly say this: with so many great pro-2nd amendment and pro-hunting groups out there who spend money responsibly, and knowing this about how the NRA spends *our* money in my own backyard, how could I ever support them?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tom HamMay 01, 2012

    Definitely prompts me to look into it. I own a few guns, and while i don't obsess over it, the thought of not having the right to have them sickens me. in that regard I’m glad there are organizations working to keep our rights intact...but me, much like you, am more focused on hunting...my guns, like my bow, is a tool i use for my passion, if i didn't hunt, i probably wouldn't own guns. That being said, i hear what River Mud is saying, there is some bad stigmas out there with the NRA. So like i said, this is prompting me to do some homework. I guess in any case it is irresponsible to be "on the fence," i certainly don't want to teach my kids to not have convictions to something! touchy subject, good post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. ErinMay 01, 2012

    I think that's one of the things I can't wrap my brain around. No single person can tweak our Bill of Rights. When Obama was elected, there was this big push to go out and buy guns because he was going to take that right away... he can't. I feel like the NRA tries to use scare tactics to gain publicity and while it works, I think it is off message.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Downeast Duck HunterMay 01, 2012

      I don't buy the logic about taking guns away, for me it's about the role of government in how they legislate, execute, and judge around the 2nd amendment. One restriction or a thousand, I don't want to see what I regard as the erosion of the 2nd amendment.

      There are powerful players who aspire to see greater gun control, I do not want to give an inch when they want to take one inch at a time or the whole 63,360. Don't forget ammunition, that's a target as well.

      I'm surprised a hired blogger from the left hasn't chimed in, or at least a volunteer.

      Delete
  5. ErinMay 01, 2012

    And an article I saw on Twitter: http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes/2012/05/power-decline-economist-proposes-nra-dominance-myth

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tom HamMay 02, 2012

    i remember when he was elected and everyone was out stocking up on guns n' amo for fear it would all be taken away! i have to admit, it got me thinking a little bit, but i didn't stock up on shells!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tom HamMay 02, 2012

    Interesting article!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Taking Turkeys to Texas

There are a few less turkeys in Maine to hunt this year. A few months ago, Maine Inland Fisheries & Wildlife in partnership with the National Wild Turkey Federation , captured and released more than 50 birds into East Texas with the hope of rebuilding their population.   “Eastern turkeys are where the restocking efforts originally began,” explained Shawn Roberts, Director of Field Operations for the National Wild Turkey Federation, “We tried in the 1920’s but it didn’t work.  We tried pen-raised birds and that didn’t work either. The only thing that was successful was to trap birds and relocate them to good habitat.” “We started this current effort in the early ‘80s and we had to begin looking outside the state to see if we could get them moved in. We didn’t want to violate The Lacey Act so we had to come up with a way to compensate the states that were giving up a resource either by trading other wildlife or paying them monetarily,” said Roberts. Texas is on the very edge o
Post a Comment
Read more

Do Outdoor Women need to toughen up?

I hope you get shot out in the forest and wolves gnaw on your dying corpse…..WHILE YOU’RE STILL ALIVE I’d like to rip off your f*$%ing head and pour gunpowder down your f*$%ing throat and light it on fire Only c*%t’s shoot animals and take pleasure in it. I hope you die a horrible painful death As I began to look at how female hunters were being bullied, I had to ask myself if it was because we were easy targets as women or if we needed to just toughen up a little. Once I started asking my fellow female hunters about their experiences, the things that they sent to me as examples of what they deal with daily made me sick to my stomach.  I’d like to meet you outside someday with a gun in my hand, I would shoot you several times and laugh over your f*$%ing body as you die like you do to those poor animals that can’t defend themselves.  MURDERER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "Generally threats are basic name calling. They include sexist remarks, racist remarks a
12 comments
Read more

Where are the women?

This week, my interview with Steve at The Maine Outdoorsman went live. Steve said yesterday 200 people hit his site viewing over 500 pages. That is a lot of people reading about little ole me and hunting. Why? When I think of women who are in the general public's eye and hunt, I can think of 2 - Country singer Miranda Lambert and Sarah Palin. Why only two? Why is the female hunter such a fascinating thing? (I should probably note that I do not have cable so any and all female hunters on the hunting stations are lost to me. I'll keep it to the general public because that's what I am familiar with.) People/media were fascinated by the fact that they could get footage of Palin and her gun, shooting (and gutting) animals but I feel like the nostalgia would be lost if they had the same footage of McCain. Lambert and her hubby Blake Shelton tweet photos of their kills, and comment on what/where they are hunting. I only know this because I follow both. That's it.
15 comments
Read more